african american man sitting and looking thoughtfully at a young white woman speaking with him about his chronically ill child

I’ve cared for three generations of family members, my mother, my twin grandchildren, and my husband. This is my 23rd year in the caregiving trenches. If you’re a long-time caregiver like me, you’ve probably heard many “you should” statements.

Often this advice comes when you least expect it and, consequently, you’re caught by surprise. These are some of the “you should” statements I’ve received.

  • Your mother said you won’t take her shopping. You should take her. She   enjoys it. 
  • You should just explain the situation.
  • Being a guardian takes time and you should stop writing to care for the twins. 
  • There’s a solution. You should hire more paid help.


There are problems with these statements. First, the person who makes the statement may not have all the facts. When I was advised to take my mother shopping, I decided to be honest. “My mother is an addictive spender and she was also swindled out of thousands of dollars.” The woman’s eyes widened in surprise and she didn’t say another word.

Another problem is that explanations don’t work with severe memory loss. My mother had vascular dementia—memory loss caused by a series of mini strokes—and her brain was damaged again and again. Mom lost the ability to follow conversation or remember it. Again, I chose to be honest. “My mother can’t track ideas or read,” I explained. “She thinks the alphabet letters are upside down.” 

Despite good intentions, the person who makes a “you should” statement may not see the big picture. Abandoning my writing career is an example. Giving up writing would mean giving up most of my identity, not a good idea. Instead, I changed the focus of my writing from health/wellness to caregiving.

Finally, the person who makes “you should” statements may not realize the cost of health care. We’ve used the services of three agencies. The first agency provided care four hours a day, two in the morning, two in the evening. These costs weren’t covered by insurance and would cost $50,000 a year out of pocket. Several months later, we deleted the evening shift to save money.

How can you reply to “you should” statements? Start by thanking the person for their interest. This makes it easier for you to introduce new ideas. 

Depending on your relationship with the person, you may choose to share some personal information. In my mother’s case, I said she suffered another mini stroke, rarely spoke, and remembered little. “She forgot her sister died,” I added. “When I told her, she started grieving all over again. It was awful.”

Be honest, but don’t overdo it. Sharing a medical fact or two is far different from sharing your loved one’s entire medical history. 

Finally, leave the door open for future contacts and friendship. Say you’re glad you met the person and would love to discuss the topic further over coffee or lunch. I usually close a conversation with, “Thank you for thinking of us and for the gift of listening.” It’s a good closing line.

Written by Harriet Hodgson
Rochester resident Harriet Hodgson has been a freelance writer for writing for 38 years, is the author of thousands of articles, and 36 books. She is a member of the Association of Health Care Journalists and the Minnesota Coalition for Death Education and Support. She is also a contributing writer for The Caregiver Space website, Open to Hope Foundation website, and The Grief Toolbox website. Harriet has appeared on more than 185 radio talk shows, including CBS Radio, and dozens of television stations, including CNN. A popular speaker, Harriet has given presentations at public health, Alzheimer’s, caregiving, and bereavement conferences. Her work is cited in Who’s Who of American Women, World Who’s Who of Women, Contemporary Authors, and other directories. All of Harriet’s work comes from her life. She is now in her 19th year of caregiving and cares for her disabled husband, John. For more information about this busy author, grandmother, wife, and caregiver please visit

Related Articles



When Carolita Johnson became a live-in caretaker for her 87-year-old mother, reimagining this new life as a multi-year writing residency helped her...

Being a Human Being

Being a Human Being

"Many of us are programmed to take action. We want to fix. We want to solve. And we take pride in fixing and solving. But sometimes there is nothing...

Popular categories

After Caregiving
Finding Meaning
Finding Support

Don't see what you're looking for? Search the library

Share your thoughts


Share your thoughts and experiences

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Join our communities

Whenever you want to talk, there’s always someone up in one of our Facebook communities.

These private Facebook groups are a space for support and encouragement — or getting it off your chest.

Join our newsletter

Thoughts on care work from Cori, our director, that hit your inbox each Monday morning (more-or-less).

There are no grand solutions, but there are countless little ways to make our lives better.

Share your insights

Caregivers have wisdom and experience to share. Researchers, product developers, and members of the media are eager to understand the nature of care work and make a difference.

We have a group specifically to connect you so we can bring about change.